Matthew 25:14-30(NRSVUE)
“The Investment Crisis”
Rev. Dr. Mary Beth Bernheisel
November 15, 2026
Well, I know it’s going to be a fun week when every commentary I read and every podcast I listen to as I prepare a sermon starts with, “This story is problematic.”
I knew that it was problematic as soon as I read it. That’s why I read the commentaries and listened to the podcasts – because I hoped to learn from someone else how to make it less problematic – for me, for you, for all of us.
Terry actually said on Tuesday that he felt bad for me that I was preaching on this text.
But I do love a theological challenge, so let’s get to it.
Will you pray with me and for me?
Holy One, you give us gifts for the service of your eternal realm and call us to use them wisely. Teach us not to hide our talents but to multiply them by your grace, that all may know the abundance of the new creation that is coming; through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
Let’s start with a definition.
Talent
A talent is a unit of money. It did not become the way we talk about it now until roughly the mid-14th century. So now we say that someone has a talent for cake decorating or tap dancing. But we didn’t start using the word talent that way until 500 years ago. But in the Ancient Near East it was literally a unit of money.
Talent = 20 years of pay = $400,000 today
It was a unit of money equal to about 20 years of wages for a day laborer. A very conservative estimate is that it would be equal to roughly $400,000 in today’s economy.
Hold that thought and we’ll come back to that.
Now I want to say a word about culture.
The events in this story do represent a real practice in the Ancient Near East. Wealthy patrons really did give money to their servants and expect the servants to trade in land or commodities on behalf of the patrons.
Now let’s go to the servants.
But instead of starting with the servant who received five talents, I want to start with the servant who got one talent and put ourselves in his place.
His master is going on a trip – he doesn’t say how long he’s going to be gone. And he calls his servants to come to him – obviously he has more than three servants, but we’re only worried about these three. He gives each of them a different sum of money.
The last one gets one talent. But before we start feeling bad for him like he got the short end of the stick, let’s remember that one talent is still an exorbitant amount of money. It’s the equivalent of 20 years of work for a day laborer. $400,000 in today’s economy.
If he loses that talent, there is no way that he can earn it back and return it to the master. And so he buries it. He keeps it safe. He makes sure that nothing happens to it while the master is gone. And when the master returns the servant is able to give back to the master exactly what was his.
If it had been me, I would’ve done exactly the same thing. Put that coin in the ground, keep it safe, go back and check on it every once in awhile, and pray that the master comes back before anything happens to that talent.
Now before we get to the other two servants, we have to deal with what the third servant says to the master when he returns.
Verse 24 says that
…the one who had received the one talent came forward, saying, ‘Master, I knew that you were a harsh man, reaping where you did not sow and gathering where you did not scatter, so I was afraid, and I went and hid your talent in the ground.’
I knew you were a harsh man.
What are we supposed to make of that?
The answer depends on how we read the parable. I think that most of us assume that when we read a parable, the king or the master or whomever has the most power in the story is supposed to represent God. But what if the master who reaps where he doesn’t sow and gathers where he did not scatter isn’t there to represent God? What if the king who kicks out the man who didn’t wear his wedding robe to the wedding feast isn’t there to represent God? That’s one way to read it.
Another way to read it is the way that John Wesley read it. And what he said about it was that
He never knew God who thinks him a hard master ~John Wesley
In other words, the slave who received one talent was afraid of the master because he did not know the master well.
There’s a third option, which is that the third servant is right – he is laboring under an oppressive system where servants do grueling work for their masters and receive nothing in return. That opens a can of worms that we’re not going to deal with this morning, so y’all feel free to discuss that at lunch and let me know tonight at dinner what you think.
So either the master isn’t supposed to fully represent God or the third servant misunderstood God’s nature.
Go with whichever one works for you.
So the third servant receives his talent, he refuses to take a risk because there’s no way he can pay it back if he loses it, he buries it in the ground, and he gives back to the master what was rightfully his.
When I follow every logical instinct, that’s the path I’m going to take as well.
Our tendency is to judge the third servant harshly, even though he did the safest and most logical thing. What if we considered his choice the norm, and it was the other two who went way above and beyond?
Then we have to ask, where did the other two get the courage to take such significant risks with someone else’s money? What motivates them?
Remember that the second servant receives
Two talents = 40 years of wages for a day laborer = $800,000 today
And the first servant receives
Five talents=100 years of wages for a day laborer = $2 million today
What drives them to take such risks with someone else’s property, knowing that if it doesn’t work out there’s no way to pay back the master?
Once again, Jesus is asking his disciples to consider – and to consider with great intentionality – how they are going to shape their lives while they wait for Christ to come back. And in turn Jesus is inviting us to consider how we are living in this in-between time. Between the world as it is now and the world as it is going to be when everything is set right. Between Jesus’s first appearance and his second coming.
And so the question turns to us. Now Jesus is talking specifically about money, but I think it’s OK for us to think about the question in terms of our whole lives – in terms of everything that we have. Not just our possessions but our actual lives. What are we doing with our lives in the in-between time?
The third slave, although he did the most logical thing and the safest thing, the third slave was obsessed with his own self-preservation. The most important question for him is, “How do I avoid negative consequences for my life?”
I imagine that he arranged his whole life around making sure nothing happened to that talent. It was constantly nagging at him. Is it still there? Should I go check on it? What happens if someone finds out where it is and takes it? And suddenly he’s like Gollum in the Lord of the Rings. His whole life is consumed by that talent and there’s no room for anything else.
And that’s no life at all.
Last week I sat in with the group studying the Book of Revelation and we talked about eschatology – about what happens at the end of all things – and one of the things that I said is that I think sometimes we worry too much about heaven and hell when, really, what we pray for every week is for God’s Kingdom to be present on earth, and maybe that’s what we should most concern ourselves with right now–whether or not our world looks increasingly more like God’s Kingdom every day. And I pointed out that when we spend too much time worrying about what happens after we die, we forget that there are plenty of people who experience hell right here on earth – either of their own making or at the hands of others.
And so when we read these stories where someone gets cast into the outer darkness where there is weeping and gnashing of teeth – is it possible that they are already living in the darkness that they have created for themselves? Is it possible that the third servant has already chosen to separate himself from the Kingdom of God by being unwilling to look outside of his own interests into the world around him? By spending his life only trying to avoid negative consequences?
Maybe he’s already made that choice for himself?
And so we’re back to the question of what motivates the other two servants to take such significant risks with money that doesn’t belong to them, with money that they’re going to have to answer for later?
The master says to the first and second servants – after they have each returned to him twice what he initially gave them – what does he say to them? He says
Enter into the joy of your master.
And I think that’s the key.
They found joy in working on behalf of their master. They found joy in taking what had been entrusted to them and offering it back to the master. They found joy in seeing his joy when they gave him twice what he had originally entrusted to them. They had spent their time while the master was away using what he had entrusted to them.
And that, friends, is the life of discipleship. I’m not going to try to tie together this parable and this sermon with our stewardship focus on Connection. Halle said all that needed to be said about how crucial it is for our church to be a place of relationship and connection.
What I want you to hear once again is that being invited into the joy of our master is not a reward that we get for living a life of discipleship. Getting to live a life of discipleship – getting to share the good news of a life with Christ – is the gift and we already have it. God has already entrusted it to us.
And the question once again turns to us. What are we going to do with the life of discipleship – the gift that God has entrusted to us? We could use it to live the way Jesus invites us to live it in the Sermon on the Mount. We could forgive people when they hurt us and do the things for other people that we would want them to do for us. We could ask the Holy Spirit to make us perfect in love for each other and we could orient ourselves to the world with generosity and kindness because that’s what Jesus did.
The alternative is to squander this gift – to hide our light under a basket instead of letting it shine, to spend our time playing it safe instead of approaching the world as people who are free to love and give and serve without counting the cost.
My prayer is that we will all find joy in seeing our master’s joy as we live this life of discipleship–this priceless gift that has been entrusted to us.
In the name of the Father, and the Son, and the Holy Spirit.
Holy God, you are our home and dwelling place forever. Thank you for giving us a gift beyond all value, the treasure of eternal life. Bless our gifts that we offer you this day. With them may we share your love with others, that all may enter into your eternal joy. Amen.